Best Pizza

Others: Best Pizza

We have 12 pizza locations listed so far. This is going to be a fun one as we find the hidden gems.

What makes the best pizza? Some things we are fans of include:

  • Quality of the crust.
  • Flavor of the sauce.
  • Compliment of the toppings.

Probably the food item I have consumed the most throughout my life. Everything from Japanese pizza toast, to the delivery of a pizza so heavy it should have shipping charges... pizza is the perfect hand held meal, and a very sociable food.


Our Current List:

    Tier 1

  1. Rutherford Family Pizza - Napa (website) - Crafted. Local to local to local. New York SLices. Huge Pies. Napa Wood-Fired Pizza. It smells like pizza!
    - Bakers Pride New York Pizza - 14", Half Pepperoni & Mushroom, half Ham & Pineapple - $26 Med
    - Bakers Pride New York Pizza - 14", Pepperoni, Mushroom & Pineapple - $29 Med
    - NY Slice Pepperoni - $8
  2. Croccante Pizza - Napa (website) - Croccante Artisan Pizza featuring Detroit and Chicago Tavern Style Pizza with a lively vibe and outdoor seating located on Pearl Street in Downtown Napa.
    Chicago Tavern Pizza
    - Cheese - $20
    - Pepperoni & Sausage - $23
    - Pesto Chicken Jalapeno - $20
    - Spicy Hawaiian - $24
    Detroit Syle Pizza
    - Bacon Mushroom - $
    - Burrata - $25
    - Croccante - $25
    - Greek Style Veggie - $25
    - Pepperoni - $24
  3. Azzuro Pizzeria e Enoteca - Napa (website) - Vibrant Italian eatery known for thin-crust pizzas plus small plates, pastas & lots of local wines.
    - Funghi Pizza - $26
  4. Bistro Don Giovanni - Napa (website) - Stalwart for Italian bistro fare with indoor fireside or outdoor, fountain-side seating options.
    - Bambini Pizza - $25
  5. Scala Osteria & Bar - Napa (website) - Traditional Southern Italian, seafood-centered recipes meant to be shared with family and friends in our warm and vibrant dining room.
    - Pizza Fritta "al forno" - $22


  6. Tier 2

  7. Filippi's Pizza Grotto - Napa (website) - Chain outpost offering pizza & red-sauce Italian staples in generous portions.
    - Fit for a King (11") - $19.25
  8. Fazerrati's Pizza - Napa (website) - Family-run pizza parlor with handmade pies, a salad bar & TVs plus draft beers & local wines.
    - Double Pepperoni - MED $27
    - Fazerratis Special - MED $29
  9. Fieldwork Brewing Company - Napa (website) - Brewpub with a variety of seasonal house beer blends, plus basic snacks, in an industrial setting.
    - Delivery Boy (Detroit-Style Pizza) - $22
  10. Papa Joe's - Napa (website) - Pick up or delivery only.
    - My Pizzas
  11. FARM at Carneros - Napa (website) - Breezy, stylish eatery serving farm-to-fork New American fare paired with a broad wine list.
    - Pepperoni Pizza - $22


  12. Tier 3

  13. Mary's Pizza Shack - Napa (website) - Family-run restaurant offering Italian comfort-food pizza & pasta staples, plus wine & beer.
    - Hawaiian Caliente (medium) - $29
  14. Evelyn's Big Italian - Fairfield (website) - Classic Italian joint offering pizzas, sandwiches, salads, calzones & take-&-bake pasta dinners.

Gone But Not Forgotten

  • The Forge Handcrafted Pizza and Brewpub - Napa (website) - Small, airy chain with Italian menu featuring wood-fired Neapolitan pies plus craft beer & wine.
    - Meat Lover - $22
  • Napa General Store - Napa (website) - Cozy, rustic breakfast & brunch place featuring a riverfront patio & a store selling local goods.
    - Genova Flat Bread - $17

Back to Top